CO129-056 - Sir Bowring - 1856 [6] — Page 325

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

34..

it, or not.

The difficulty of dealing with this question of assessment consists in the multitude of special cases, the circumstances of each of which must be considered. That is to say, there will be that difficulty unless you reduce the matter to a question of the strictly legal rights of the Brown, which I do not think you ought to do. The reclaimed land has been occupied in several instances by occupants, each paying a consideration in succession doubtless. There was one case where the land after being reclaimed by an individual reverted to Government, the Lot to which it was attached had been repurchased by Government, granted out and it has been since again granted to other persons at the full value. I do not believe that the Government paid anything for the improvements - That was Lot 41.

I thought the whole of that case a great hardship - Locality is another Matter for equitable consideration. The centre of Victoria being much more valuable than either the East or West end, I think that the rates of assessment ought to be proportionally higher. I would suggest that the Government should provide for some of these special cases by repaying to those who have reclaimed land the amount expended; (Making all equitable allowances), and, having done so, to put them and their new buildings upon the same footing in all respects as other occupiers and their Lots. Otherwise it will be impossible to avoid an inequality of conditions, which will be a great injustice to the holders of land south of the Queen's Road, and indeed all over the whole of the Colony.

Edit History

2026-05-18 03:17:32 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
34.. it, or not. The difficulty of dealing with this question of assessment consists in the multitude of special cases, the circumstances of each of which must be considered. That is to say, there will be that difficulty unless you reduce the matter to a question of the strictly legal rights of the Brown, which I do not think you ought to do. The reclaimed land has been occupied in several instances by occupants, each paying a consideration in succession doubtless. There was one case where the land after being reclaimed by an individual reverted to Government, the Lot to which it was attached had been repurchased by Government, granted out and it has been since again granted to other persons at the full value. I do not believe that the Government paid anything for the improvements - That was Lot 41. I thought the whole of that case a great hardship - Locality is another Matter for equitable consideration. The centre of Victoria being much more valuable than either the East or West end, I think that the rates of assessment ought to be proportionally higher. I would suggest that the Government should provide for some of these special cases by repaying to those who have reclaimed land the amount expended; (Making all equitable allowances), and, having done so, to put them and their new buildings upon the same footing in all respects as other occupiers and their Lots. Otherwise it will be impossible to avoid an inequality of conditions, which will be a great injustice to the holders of land south of the Queen's Road, and indeed all over the whole of the Colony.
Baseline (Original)
34.. it, or not. The difficulty of dealing with this question of assessment consists in the multitude of special cases, the circumstances of each of which must be considered. That is to say, there will be that difficulty unkers you reduce the matter to a question of the strictly legal rights of the Brown, which I do not think you ought to do. The reclaimed land has been occupist in several instances by, goccupants, each paying a consideration a succession doubtless. There was one case where au. the land after being reclaimed by as individual reverted to Government, The Lot to which it was attached. had been repurchased by Govern wait, granted out and it has been since again to other persons at the full value. I do not believe that the Government paid anything for the improvements - That was Lot 41 = _ a 323 I thought the whole of that case great hardship - Locality is another Matter for equitable consideration. The centre of Victoria being much more valuable than either the East or West end, I think that the rates of assessment ought to be proportionally higher. I would suggest that the Government shout provide for some of these Special by repaying to those who have reclaimed land the amount expended; Castlet (Making all equitable allowances), and, having dove 10, to put them and their new buildings upon the same other As with - footing in all respects. occupiers and their Lots. Otherwise it will be impossible. to avoid aw insequality of conditions, which will be a great injustice to the holders of land south of the Queen's Road, and indeed all over the whole of the Colony, and A i
2026-05-18 03:17:32 · Baseline
View content

34..

it, or not.

The difficulty of dealing with this question of assessment consists in the multitude of special cases, the circumstances of each of which must be considered. That is to say, there will be that difficulty unkers you

reduce the matter to a question of the strictly legal rights of the Brown, which I do not think you ought to do. The reclaimed land has been occupist in several instances by, goccupants, each paying a consideration

a succession

doubtless. There was one case where

au.

the land after being reclaimed by as

individual reverted to Government, The Lot to which it was attached.

had been repurchased by Govern wait, granted out

and it has been since

again

to other persons at the full

value. I do not believe that the

Government paid anything for the improvements - That was Lot 41 = _

a

323

I thought the whole of that case

great hardship - Locality is another Matter for equitable consideration. The centre of Victoria being much

more valuable than either the East or West end, I think that the rates of assessment ought to be proportionally higher. I would suggest that the Government shout provide for some of these

Special by repaying to those who have reclaimed land the amount expended;

Castlet

(Making all equitable allowances), and, having dove 10, to put them and their new buildings upon the same

other

As with

- footing in all respects. occupiers and their Lots. Otherwise it will be impossible.

to avoid aw

insequality of conditions, which will be a great injustice to the holders of land south of the Queen's Road, and indeed all

over the whole of the Colony,

and

A

i

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.